Short answer: in the AiTradely vs Trade Ideas choice, Trade Ideas is the more focused tool if you day trade US stocks and want a market-wide scanner. AiTradely suits you better if you trade crypto, forex, gold or stocks across different timeframes and want to build and test your own rules. They solve different problems, so the right pick depends mostly on what you trade and how often.
AiTradely vs Trade Ideas: the core difference
Trade Ideas is a specialist product built around US stock trading, mainly intraday. Its Holly AI is its best-known feature, and it has been part of the product for years. If your whole routine is finding active US stocks each morning, that focus is a real strength.
AiTradely is an AI trading analyst on live market data. It covers crypto, forex, gold and other commodities, and stocks. It does not cover indices. You ask the AI about an asset and it answers from live prices, indicators and news. It is not a broker, not a signal seller, and it does not trade for anyone.
So the first question is simple: what do you trade? If it is only US stocks, Trade Ideas is built for you. If you trade anything outside US stocks, it may not cover your markets, and AiTradely might.
Who each one is for
Trade Ideas fits you if:
- You day trade US stocks, probably most days.
- You want a scanner that looks across the whole US market for candidates.
- You are happy to work in a desktop-style setup and treat trading as close to a full-time activity.
AiTradely fits you if:
- You trade crypto, forex, gold or stocks, or move between them.
- You trade on any timeframe from 5 minutes to the daily chart, including swing trades.
- You would rather describe your own rules and have them tested than follow ideas someone else generated.
- You want the app on your phone, with alerts when your conditions fire.
Check each provider's own site for current pricing and terms before you decide.
How each works day to day
With Trade Ideas, the routine usually starts with scanning. You look at the candidates the platform surfaces, look at the AI-generated ideas, and decide which to act on. It is a workflow built around speed and volume in one market.
With AiTradely, the routine is closer to having an analyst you can question:
- Open an asset and read the daily analysis, which gives its direction and the reasoning written out.
- Ask the AI follow-up questions, such as what the RSI is saying or which news matters.
- Check the economic calendar for events that could move the asset.
- Pick a timeframe and look at a trade plan, which is an entry, a stop and a target built by rules from the chart.
- Or build your own strategy in the no-code builder. You pick conditions such as RSI, MACD, moving averages, Bollinger Bands, volume or price levels, backtest them on history, and set an alert.
If you decide to act, you can place the trade from the app on your own cTrader or MetaTrader 5 account. The AI never places a trade on its own. You decide and you click.
What each one does not do
Being clear about limits matters more than any feature list.
Where Trade Ideas is stronger. For US intraday stock trading, it is the specialist. It is designed for scanning the US market and has years of work behind its AI. AiTradely does not try to be a market-wide scanner for US stocks. It analyses the assets you choose from its coverage. If scanning thousands of US stocks every morning is your edge, Trade Ideas is the better fit.
What Trade Ideas does not cover. Its focus is US stocks, so it is not the place to look if you trade forex pairs, crypto or gold.
What AiTradely does not do. It does not trade for you, it does not sell signals, and it does not cover indices. Its strategy builder has no condition for chart patterns such as head and shoulders, double tops, triangles or flags, and none for an opening range. You can still use conditions such as market structure breaks, candle patterns, RSI divergence and volume, but if your method depends on drawn patterns, you will have to read those on the chart yourself.
Neither tool removes risk. A tested rule or an AI idea is an input to your decision, not a result you can count on.
Side by side in short
Trade Ideas covers US stocks, leans toward intraday day trading, and centres on scanning and AI-generated ideas. AiTradely covers crypto, forex, gold and other commodities, and stocks, works on timeframes from 5 minutes to daily, and centres on analysis, trade plans and rules you build yourself.
Trade Ideas is stronger for a dedicated US day trader who wants market-wide scanning. AiTradely is stronger for a trader who works across several markets, wants to test their own conditions, and values a phone-first app with alerts. If you are unsure which camp you are in, AI trading analysis vs traditional tools explains where AI helps and where it does not.
Common questions
01Is Trade Ideas good for forex or crypto?
It is built around US stocks, so it is not designed for forex or crypto. Traders in those markets usually need a different tool.
02Does AiTradely give buy and sell signals like Trade Ideas?
AiTradely gives a daily analysis with reasoning and trade plans built by rules from the chart. It is not a signal seller, and the decision to trade is always yours.
03Can I use both?
Yes. Some traders use a specialist US stock scanner for one market and a broader analysis tool for the others. They do not conflict.
04Which is better for a beginner?
It depends on the market. A beginner trading forex or crypto will find Trade Ideas does not cover those. For a first step in forex, see how to start forex trading.
Putting it into practice
Before choosing, write down the markets you trade and the timeframe you trade them on. If the list is only US stocks on intraday charts, a specialist scanner is worth a serious look. If it is anything wider, or you want to test your own conditions, a broader tool fits better. Whichever you pick, size every position against your stop, and the position size calculator helps with that.
If your list is wider than US stocks, the AiTradely app is where you can take this further: ask the AI about an asset you follow, then turn one of your own conditions into a backtested alert in the strategy builder. The features page shows what else is there.
Nothing here is financial advice. A tool can surface ideas or test rules, but it cannot remove the risk of loss on any trade you place.
AiTradelyYour AI trading analyst, in your pocketAI analysis for gold, forex and stocks. Build and backtest strategies, get signals, and trade from your own broker account.
On your phoneScan for the app